Amy Schumer Reduces Price on Beloved Brooklyn Townhouse—A Tender Farewell to a Family Home
Comedian and actress Amy Schumer is saying a bittersweet goodbye to her Brooklyn Heights townhouse, slashing more than $1.25 million off the price less than three months after listing it. The cozy family home, which she and her husband Chris Fischer lovingly transformed, was originally listed for $14 million in March. Now, with a reduced asking price of $12.75 million, the couple is ready to pass on this special place as they move closer to their son’s school in Manhattan.
The bright and inviting living room of Amy Schumer’s Brooklyn townhouse combines classic charm with modern comfort, perfect for family gatherings and relaxing evenings. Source - Realtor.com
A Home Made with Love: More Than Just Bricks and Mortar
Amy and Chris purchased the five-bedroom, 3.5-bath townhouse in 2022 for $12.25 million, then poured their hearts into making it their own. Though the house offers 5,500 square feet—modest by celebrity standards—it was a spacious sanctuary filled with laughter and quiet moments alike.
“We loved what we moved into,” Amy shared with the Wall Street Journal, “but we've definitely made it our own.” Their renovations imbued the home with warmth and character—a true reflection of their life together.
One of the most striking transformations was the backyard, reimagined by renowned landscape architect Michael Van Valkenburgh. Though the outdoor space was intimate, the couple crafted a serene retreat—where morning coffees could be sipped in sunlight filtering through leaves, and evening dinners could unfold under the soft glow of string lights.
Inside, the home welcomes you with a soothing palette and thoughtful touches: two inviting entertaining rooms, a custom wine cellar perfect for celebrations, a gym to stay energized, a cozy library for quiet reading, and a palatial primary suite complete with its own crackling fireplace and a spa-like bathroom. Amy described it as a place “ready for more people,” filled with possibility.
The stylish kitchen in Amy Schumer’s Brooklyn Heights home boasts contemporary design and functional space, ideal for cooking and entertaining. Source - Realtor.com
History and Charm Wrapped in Brooklyn’s Embrace
Built in 1829, the townhouse is steeped in history, its stately façade famously featured in the movie Moonstruck, serving as the Castorini family’s home. The design beautifully blends Brooklyn’s historic character with a New Orleans-inspired aesthetic—a heartfelt nod to Amy and Chris’s Louisiana residence.
The New Orleans-style terrace, framed by intricate wrought iron, opens gracefully to a fenced backyard—a rare jewel in the heart of the city. The primary bathroom features an original marble soaking tub, dual fireplaces, and exquisite marble tiling, creating an atmosphere of timeless elegance.
Careful restorations maintain the home's integrity, from the mansard roof to new ironwork fencing and steel-reinforced stairs. This isn’t just a house—it’s a lovingly preserved piece of Brooklyn’s architectural legacy.
The serene primary bedroom in Amy Schumer’s Brooklyn townhouse offers a cozy retreat with luxurious touches and abundant natural light. Source - Realtor.com
Moving On: A New Chapter for the Schumer-Fischer Family
Amy explained that the decision to relocate to Manhattan revolves around their son, Gene.
“He got into a good school and we’re too lazy to commute 45 minutes to take our son to school every day,” she joked, capturing the relatable mix of parenthood and practicality.
Though they will dearly miss the neighborhood’s safety, beauty, and sense of community, the family is excited for the new chapter ahead. Amy’s Instagram post was filled with affection:
“Brooklyn heights two parking spots. Backyard. Four bedrooms ... Ever best hood ever. One block from Brooklyn Bridge park and all the schools are so close. Will miss it so much and loved our three years here. Quite safe and beautiful.”
While the exact Manhattan address remains private, their property portfolio includes a dreamy New Orleans home Amy calls a “dream come true,” a place where their family finds joy and peace.
The spa-like bathroom in Amy Schumer’s Brooklyn Heights home showcases timeless elegance with its marble soaking tub and sophisticated design details. Source - Realtor.com
People Also Ask
Why did Amy Schumer reduce the price on her Brooklyn townhouse?
Amy and Chris lowered the price by over $1.25 million to attract buyers more quickly. Their move to Manhattan to be closer to their son’s school motivates their desire to sell promptly.
How much profit did Amy Schumer make on the townhouse?
After renovations and price reductions, the couple stands to make approximately $500,000 profit, having originally bought the home for $12.25 million.
What renovations did they do to the Brooklyn home?
Significant renovations included a major backyard overhaul by landscape architect Michael Van Valkenburgh, interior upgrades, and careful preservation of the home’s historic charm.
Where else does Amy Schumer own property?
Amy and Chris also own a beautifully renovated home in New Orleans, which Amy describes as her “dream, dramatic New Orleans hang.” In 2016, Amy famously bought back her family farm, reclaiming a cherished piece of her past.
The charming balcony of Amy Schumer’s Brooklyn Heights home offers a relaxing outdoor space with cushioned seating and a vibrant astroturf area for added comfort. Source - Realtor.com
A Loving Goodbye, and Hope for New Beginnings
Amy Schumer’s Brooklyn townhouse is more than just bricks and mortar—it’s a home brimming with warmth, memories, and history. As they prepare to leave, there’s a palpable sense of gratitude and tenderness for the years spent within its walls.
Though this chapter closes with a touch of sadness, Amy and her family carry with them the true essence of home—the love and connection that no address can contain. As they embark on their new life in Manhattan, hope blooms for fresh memories, laughter, and love to fill their next sanctuary.
Because a home is wherever the heart is, and theirs is ready to embrace the future.
Source: Property details and listing information courtesy of Realtor.com.
