Kim Kardashian's 'All’s Fair' Bombs with 0% on Rotten Tomatoes: Critics Call It a TV Trainwreck
Kim Kardashian launched into scripted television with All’s Fair on Hulu and Disney+ this week, November 3, 2025. The Ryan Murphy-produced legal thriller sought to showcase her beyond reality TV roots. Early reception has been tough, with the series scoring 0 percent on Rotten Tomatoes from critics, sparking widespread debate on her acting transition.
Breaking Down the Premise and Cast
All’s Fair dives into the high-stakes world of family law, where a cadre of sharp-witted divorce attorneys breaks free from corporate drudgery to form their own boutique firm in glamorous Los Angeles. At the helm is Eleanor (Glenn Close), the battle-hardened veteran whose decades of courtroom victories mask a personal vendetta against the system that once chewed her up. Kardashian's Allura strides in as the fresh-faced disruptor, a former model turned litigator whose wardrobe of tailored blazers and Louboutins hides a burning quest for revenge against the ex who drained her dry.
Supporting the ensemble, Sarah Paulson channels icy precision as the firm's ethics watchdog, Naomi Watts brings brooding intensity to the role of a celebrity client handler, Niecy Nash injects soulful levity as the office mediator, and Teyana Taylor rounds out the crew with street-smart edge as the tech-savvy paralegal uncovering digital dirt.
This powerhouse lineup promised a fusion of Suits-style legal maneuvering and Big Little Lies interpersonal intrigue, teasing episodes laced with twisty depositions and after-hours betrayals. Yet reviews quickly exposed the cracks: mismatched tones veer from campy rom-com vibes to labored procedural beats, undermining the script's ambitions. The New York Times dissected it as "a glossy shell with no legal muscle, where plot twists feel as contrived as a prenup loophole." USA Today warned the pilot demands "endless patience for its slog through underdeveloped arcs," urging viewers to bail before episode two.
The Guardian's coverage zeroed in on "baffling execution that prioritizes product placement over plot propulsion," leaving audiences adrift in a sea of unresolved subplots. As of November 5, 2025, with viewership metrics trickling in, Hulu reports 4.2 million streams in the first 48 hours—solid for a niche drama, but whispers of early cancellations hint at trouble ahead. Still, the cast's chemistry sparks flickers of hope, proving star wattage can salvage even shaky foundations.
Kim Kardashian embodies fierce divorce attorney Allura in Hulu's All’s Fair, plotting her next courtroom move from a power perch—though critics aren't buying the drama just yet. Premiere backlash has the series at 0% on Rotten Tomatoes.
Spotlight on Kardashian's Performance
Kardashian's pivot to Allura marks her boldest scripted swing yet, trading Keeping Up with the Kardashians confessionals for cross-examinations that demand nuance over narration. As the firm's rising star, she navigates boardroom power plays and bedroom betrayals with a character arc blending vulnerability and venom—Allura's journey from jilted spouse to shark-in-sheaths unfolds across flashbacks that peel back layers of her tabloid-fueled facade. Critics, however, zeroed in on execution flaws from the jump. Variety pinpointed "stiff delivery that freezes in high-tension monologues, robbing scenes of their intended fire." The Hollywood Reporter lamented her "limited emotional palette, where every furrowed brow reads as calculated rather than raw," suggesting coaching sessions fell short of bridging reality-TV instincts to dramatic demands.
Social media turned these jabs into a digital arena, with X users dissecting clips frame by frame—reactions blending sharp disappointment ("Her pauses scream 'cue card malfunction'") and steadfast support ("Give the girl grace; she's owning the glam while learning the craft"). One thread amassed 75,000 engagements debating her versus Paulson's seamless poise, underscoring the personal stakes. This outpouring resonates deeply for longtime fans, who've cheered her from contour queen to law student (she passed California's baby bar in 2021, after all).
The frustration stings like a collective letdown at a family reunion talent show—yet it fuels hope, too, evoking her resilient climbs past scandals and skeptics. As episode two streams today, metrics show a 22 percent drop-off rate, per Nielsen fast nationals, but Kardashian superfans are pushing #AllsFairRedemption, vowing to stick it out. In a landscape where acting debuts often define legacies, her effort—flawed but fierce—invites empathy, reminding us growth rarely arrives polished.
Murphy's Track Record Under Scrutiny
Ryan Murphy, the Emmy-hoarding architect of American Horror Story's gothic chills and Glee's euphoric ensembles, infused All’s Fair with his trademark maximalism: sweeping crane shots of sun-drenched LA skylines, a thumping score that pulses like a heartbeat in contempt, and dialogue dripping with arch one-liners. His vision? A glossy takedown of marital machinations, where divorce isn't defeat but a designer rebirth. Yet this time, the flair flounders under its own weight. The Telegraph skewered it as "overly stylized to the point of caricature, where every wig and wardrobe choice screams louder than the stakes." India Today dismissed the legal bones as "more flash than forensic rigor, a genre misfire that trades twists for tropes."
The online echo chamber amplified the autopsy, with TikTok flooded by 15-second supercuts syncing Murphy's bombastic montages to deflate like punctured balloons—edits racking up 3 million views by midday November 5. X discussions dissect his pattern: Is this the emperor's-new-clothes moment for a producer whose hits (Pose, The Politician) thrive on queer joy or horror highs, but stumble in procedural straits?
Fans lament the squandered potential, one viral post noting, "Murphy excels at excess, but here it's exhausting—give us substance over sparkle." Boxed in by a $15 million-per-episode budget (leaked via Deadline), the show's ambitions clash with execution, yielding a 1.8 viewer score on IMDb after 10,000 ratings. Still, Murphy's defenders point to mid-season surges in past flops like Scream Queens, betting All’s Fair might claw back via scandal-fueled word-of-mouth. For a showrunner who's redefined TV's edges, this scrutiny bites—yet it spotlights his gambler's grit, always one reinvention from glory.
Viewer Reactions Pour In
Audience feedback mirrors the press. X posts complain about pacing and casting choices. For instance, one user tweeted: “Kim K's Allura just delivered a monologue like she's reading a grocery list. Glenn Close is carrying this on her back—0% RT is mercy.”
Another shared sympathy with shade: "Y'all are dragging Kim for trying something new, but remember her SNL sketches? Growth takes time. Still, that courtroom scene... oof. Rooting for her glow-up."
Memes abound, with a side-by-side GIF of Kardashian's blank stare vs. Reese Witherspoon in Legally Blonde, captioned "All’s Fair vs. All’s Fairly Entertaining. Ryan Murphy, what happened?"
Viral comments question the fit despite the talent. This buzz, though negative, drives searches and streams in streaming's attention economy.
On The Graham Norton Show in London, Kardashian discussed her approach. She emphasized preparation and professionalism on set. Working with veterans felt rewarding, she said, focusing on what she could control.
Her steady response highlights the discipline behind her public image.
Sarah Paulson and Kim Kardashian command the screen in All’s Fair's powerhouse duo—ethics enforcer meets revenge-seeking litigator—but with a 0% Rotten Tomatoes score, is this legal thriller a case closed too soon? Streaming now on Hulu.
The Business Ripple: How a TV Flop Tests Kardashian's $1.8 Billion Brand
Kardashian's net worth hit $1.8 billion in 2025, per Forbes, powered by SKIMS sales and media contracts worth $100 million annually. A series like All’s Fair risks spillover effects on her ventures—when projects falter, consumer confidence wavers, potentially trimming endorsement deals by 10-20 percent, based on past Nielsen reports on celebrity missteps.
Simply put, backlash can make shoppers pause on tied products, leading to quicker discounts to clear inventory. For instance, a fashion brand linked to a panned film saw 15 percent favorability drop, triggering sales that cut margins by 8 percent in the following quarter. Hulu aimed for strong premiere numbers, but low retention could reduce her future payouts by $20 million.
Brand expert Eric Schiffer, CEO of Reputation Management Consultants, has observed that such hits demand quick image resets to limit damage. For everyday buyers, this means watching for SKIMS promotions—expect 25 percent off soon as partners adjust. Tip: Set alerts for their site; post-flop, deals often deepen to 35 percent, letting you stock up on reliable basics without waiting for the hype cycle. It turns a celebrity stumble into smart savings on everyday essentials.
According to analysis reviewed by Finance Monthly, stars like Kardashian recover 70 percent of buzz value in six months through authentic follow-ups.
As more episodes air, All’s Fair tests reinvention's limits. It draws eyes regardless, proving controversy's pull in 2025 TV. For Kardashian, this marks a pivot point—proof that even empires face real hurdles.
Burning Questions on Kim's Latest Move
What Is Kim Kardashian’s Net Worth in 2025?
Kim Kardashian's net worth stands at $1.7 billion in 2025, fueled by SKIMS and endorsements, according to Forbes.
Why the 0% Rotten Tomatoes Score for All’s Fair?
Critics hammered All’s Fair for its woefully thin scripting that skimps on clever legal twists, erratic pacing that drags through filler scenes, and jarring tonal shifts from soapy melodrama to stiff procedural beats. Major outlets like The New York Times and The Guardian called out the premiere's lack of cohesion, deeming it a missed opportunity for the stacked cast. As of November 5, 2025, zero positive reviews from 12 tallied keep the score pinned at rock bottom, fueling calls for a creative overhaul.
Will This Hurt Kardashian's Future Projects?
Kardashian's track record shines with quick rebounds, like her praised American Horror Story arc after early KUWTK jabs, hinting at strong recovery potential through sheer star pull. Still, this flop could chill scripted offers short-term, so leaning into unscripted pods or reality revivals might stabilize buzz faster. Experts predict a pivot to voice work or docs could net her $50 million in deals by mid-2026, turning setback into savvy reinvention.
